Payload Review - Blast Off
Payload is a drafting, set collection and occasional auction game with light interaction entirely expressed through cards and a few dice. Thematically, players are CEO’s managing a space company, each racing to ensure their tech is the fastest to fulfil contracts on offer and keep the company afloat. In practice, Payload plays out as an order-of-operations efficiency puzzle, where managing the flow of capital is perhaps the most crucial element to not only winning, but making it to the endgame at all.
The copy of Payload I was provided for review is a prototype, yet the production itself is quite solid with the sturdy nature of the box and the durable plastic cardstock standout features – ideally the full production copies available in the recently launched KickStarter campaign won’t make any significant changes in this regard. A 28+ page rulebook gives a slightly false impression of how heavy the game is; usually a rulebook of this size requires meticulous and repeated study, whereas Payload is fairly simple to pick up, provided you can make it past the first nine pages outlining setup, gameplay concepts and iconography in detail before running through the steps of a round. I’m one of those people that struggles with this layout in a rulebook favoured by publishers like Spielworxx (La Granja, El Burro and Yinzi come to mind) and would prefer less frontloading. But alas, that’s the rub of many boardgames and concepts at large – it’s only simple once you understand it. While it lacks some clarity in interactions with the included solo bot, examples are plentiful throughout the rest of the rules and greatly assist understanding.
The included 110 cards consist of Rocket Parts in four types, Engineer Cards which will synergise with certain Rocket Parts, Payload cards which players bid to compete for, Operation cards that provide powerful actions during the game and a number of cards which let players track their game state or remind them of the turn structure.
Each round in Payload, players take turns to resolve up to four Optional Actions before taking two Main Actions. These must be done in this order however, and no Optional Action can be done more than once per turn. The most pivotal of the Optional Actions is ‘Initiate a Bid’, where players try and low-ball one another for a Payload card. These deliver a cash injection and provide 1-3 tiers of increasing Attributes a finished Rocket requires for that Payload to launch successfully. Given the game doesn’t end until all players have launched a second Payload or one player has launched their third, these cards are crucial to the timing and tempo of the game.
There are a few twists to this action, namely that bidding is obfuscated by the use of codewords which let other players know the range you’re bidding it but not quite an exact number, and that what you bid is the amount you’ll receive, not pay – after all, the Payload contract is going to end up with the person who charges the least money to the client. And money in Payload is tight – the largest funding top-ups will come in from Payload bids, while a few of the ‘Operations’ cards like Deep Scan and Reload will dole out lower amounts more reliably. It’s also possible to sell previously purchased Rocket Parts back to the Market at cost which is akin to a temporary interest free loan. Running out of money in Payload is a death sentence, so knowing exactly when to buy, sell and bid is crucial to staying in the game. When not concerned with the size of their coffers, players will fixate on four other factors; Payload Safety, Thrust, Stability and Risk. One or more of these icons can be found on almost every card in the game and their totals determine whether a Payload can be launched and more importantly, can be done safely. But to launch, we must have a complete working Rocket in the first place.
The Main Actions in Payload make this space delivery dream a possibility through purchasing Rocket Parts and hiring Engineers from their respective market rows, with each position in the row denoting the card cost. The first Part or Engineer is $1, while the fourth is $4 and whenever something is purchased, the rest slide down and reduce in cost. Players are limited to five Rocket Parts and five Engineers total, meaning that going all out to buy or hire isn’t a long-term strategy and may result in a lot of selling back to the market. Rocket parts can be upgraded through the ‘Innovate’ or ‘Breakthrough’ Operations cards which frequently increases their Safety/Thrust/Stability while lowering their Risk but spending too long gussying up a rocket allows competing players to get the jump on your budding space enterprise.
Rockets love Engineers, so the story goes, and all but the most Junior specialise in a specific Rocket part denoted by their name and matching icon in the top right of their card. While a Guidance Engineer can sit under any old Nozzle, pairing them with one of a matching colour will increase the efficacy of that Engineer and thus the Rocket itself. Paired matching-coloured Rocket parts accumulate Shields, a mitigating resource that can assist a Payload launch, while also matching the Rocket Parts’ colours to the target Payload colour reduces the launch risk by 1 for each part. Much of this minor mathing out can be hard to remember for the first few games despite the cards trying their best to denote where these synergies are applicable. Risk is inherent to the entire enterprise and nowhere is it more impactful than launch day.
You didn’t think launching a rocket was going to be risk-free, did you? Running along the bottom right of each Rocket part is the Risk number, the total of which needs to be exceeded. Payload’s three dice decide if a launch was under or over prepared. The single red die is rolled each round by the first player and sets the ‘Weather’, with higher numbers signalling clearer weather and a higher chance for success. Because this affects every player for the round, something low like a 1 or 2 could delay a launch until clearer skies are on the way. The two black dice symbolise the inherent risk of launching a rocket – regardless of how much prep work and mitigation is done, risk can’t be eradicated entirely. If the sum total of all three dice (or Shields spent to increase a rolled number) meets or exceeds the total calculated Risk between the Rocket and Payload, the launch is successful.
Players can pay Shields to keep parts of their spent Rocket, but it’s a costly exercise and often only one or two parts are worth saving. The Payload contract is completed, and the card flipped to show the immediate and ongoing rewards. While the game may end with every players’ second Payload launch or the first to launch a third, final scoring comes from a range of factors including leftover parts, Payload-matching Engineers and penalties from leaving a Payload contract unfulfilled. Racing to finish first but with low-reward Payloads and sub-par Rocket parts can still result in a loss, so keeping an eye on each opponent is key to knowing when to push for the end.
Payload is a tidy little package of a game which streamlines many aspects of the industry it’s exploring to keep the game grounded and more approachable. However, the theme and sterile art won’t cater to all tastes, something the designers themselves have acknowledged on their Campaign page. Dice rolls are always going to rub some players the wrong way, especially on top of many euro-game mechanisms, but the dice also highlight the race aspect of the business; being too conservative or focusing too much on synergy will mean running slower than your competition, while playing too fast and loose will see your rocket sputter-nik. Similarly, luck of the card rows can mean being stuck without a way to get precisely what you want without overpaying for it, especially when multiple players might all be competing for the same matching colours or icons for their Payload launches. The included ‘Tycoon’ solo mode is robust enough to provide a challenge without a high overhead, but as is the case with even mildly interactive games, loses some of the spark that comes with live opponents, especially at higher player counts where competition for Parts is fiercer.
A mix of luck, tactics and strategy pushes Payload into a midweight category that feels too long for a filler but not quite heady enough to be the centrepiece of a heavy gamers’ evening. In that way it reminds me of Knarr, Forest Shuffle or Faraway that take up a similar shelf space and playtime.
Payload was reviewed using an advance copy kindly supplied by the publisher. You can back Payload on KickStarter by following this link.







